Firms react positively to CC ten-year tender plan

Posted by | October 22, 2013 | Latest Audit Information & News

Big Four and mid-tier firms have showed strong support for the Competition Commission’s final report on the statutory audit market. There has been widespread acceptance that change was needed within the audit market.

James Chalmers, head of assurance at PwC, said: ‘This is a sensible outcome. After almost two years and a thorough process, the Competition Commission has put forward a significant package of proposals, including mandatory re-tendering every ten years, increased accountability of auditors to audit committees, and additional responsibilities for the Financial Reporting Council (FRC). Taken together, these measures will enhance competition, transparency and quality.’

The original proposal for five-year mandatory tendering was widely criticised and seen as too disruptive and costly. The new timescale has been welcomed as building on the FRC’s work to introduce a ten year ‘comply or explain’ tendering process.

Tony Cates, EMA head of audit at KPMG, said: ‘We believe that a ten-year tender process strikes a better balance between, on the one hand, allowing an auditor to get under the skin of complex, global businesses and provide real insight and management challenge while, on the other hand, ensuring an effective and rigorous tender process to choose the best auditor.’

Hywel Ball, managing partner assurance at EY stated: ‘Overall the process and evidence over two years has confirmed that competition between audit firms is healthy and robust and that for the most part audits are done well – the service we provide to our clients is effective and diligent.’

ICAEW chief executive Michael Izza said that the underlying requirement is for ‘those that buy audit services to recognise that real quality as well as niche expertise exist outside the largest professional service firms’.

Responses from firms in the mid-tier are suggesting that the CC’s measures will support this process. David Herbinet, head of UK public interest markets at Mazars, says: ‘The door that was once shut and firmly bolted to firms like ours has now at least been nudged ajar. Only a few years ago we had a truly ossified market, with barely any tendering, let alone change of auditors. We’ve always accepted that change wouldn’t happen overnight, but from today it is now clear that there is no alternative but to change.’

Grant Thornton CEO Scott Barnes said the CC report ‘dispels the misconception that there is an issue of quality or capability outside of the largest firms’, and has put the issues of competition and choice to the forefront.

James Roberts, senior audit partner, BDO argues that ‘this essential shift in attitudes to governance, to reject the notion that an auditor can remain in place for 100 years without a competitive tender, should bring about real change in the market and encourage genuine and fair competition’. Roberts also warned that ‘we are under no illusion that, despite the investigation, the establishment of real and sufficient competition is a long-term undertaking’.

Article from accountancy live

1456 total views, 1 today

Tags: , , , ,